Standing on the Side of Humanity: Why Opposing Antisemitism and Defending Gaza Are One Single Cause
In our current global climate, public discourse often falls into a divisive trap that forces us to choose between two seemingly opposing sides. We are frequently told that we must either support the safety of the Jewish community or advocate for the survival and rights of Palestinians. However, this black and white logic misleads our core understanding of human rights. In reality, opposing antisemitism and condemning the humanitarian catastrophe or potential genocide in Gaza are not in conflict; they are two expressions of the exact same universal value. If we hold firm to the principle that every human being deserves dignity and safety, then we must simultaneously reject hate crimes against Jewish people and speak out for the suffering people in Gaza.
To clarify this issue, we must first learn to distinguish between discrimination against a people and the critique of state actions. Antisemitism is a prejudice and hatred based on ethnic and religious identity; it is a real and rising threat that must be condemned by all of humanity without hesitation. At the same time, questioning military actions or government policies, especially when those actions lead to massive civilian casualties and a humanitarian disaster, is a matter of political and legal accountability. Conflating these two does a disservice to both causes, as it weakens the fight against actual antisemitism and obstructs the international community’s ability to protect victims of human rights abuses. True moral courage lies in the ability to recognize different forms of suffering without feeling the need to hate one group in order to sympathize with another.
From a deeper perspective of human interaction, we can look to the lessons learned in parenting and family dynamics. As we often discuss, simply saying “no” or setting a rigid boundary is rarely enough to solve a root problem; real change and growth come from the quality of the relationship and the depth of interaction. The same principle applies to global harmony. It is not enough to merely reject hate in words; we must build a culture of empathy that acknowledges the historical trauma of the Jewish people while also facing the current existential crisis of the Palestinian people. This level of interaction requires us to see the humanity in everyone rather than reducing individuals to political symbols or enemies.
Ultimately, the heart of this discussion is whether we believe in the universality of human rights. Security should not be a zero-sum game where the survival of one group depends on the erasure of another. When we stand against inhumane treatment in Gaza, we are actually defending the very international standards meant to protect everyone, including Jewish communities, from tyranny and violence. When we oppose antisemitism, we are upholding the foundations of a pluralistic and civilized society. Only when we refuse to be forced into taking sides, and instead stand firmly on the side of humanity, can we truly build a world where every child can grow up in peace and safety.
Discover more from Fr. Bill Mok
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.